Out-of-state? Free MRI review4.9 ★ · 633 Google reviewsBoard-certified spine surgeonSame-day spine surgeryCall (424) 217-7463
Out-of-state? Free MRI review + telehealth consult before you travel 4.9 ★ · 633 Google reviews Board-certified — American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery Minimally invasive, same-day spine surgery in Beverly Hills Call (424) 217-7463

Video · The Doctors segment

The Doctors – Car Seat Hack Poses Decapitation Risk

Watch the video

The Doctors: Car Seat Hack Poses Decapitation Risk · Dr. Hooman Melamed on YouTube

Published on YouTube Length 3:42

About this video

The hosts look at a viral mom hack: a fabric band across a child's forehead to stop the head drooping in a car seat, which the mother later warned could lead to internal decapitation. Dr. Melamed says these bands are dangerous, explains that internal decapitation means the skull and neck separate internally, and says the band could also slip down around the neck or block the mouth. He tells parents to buy only accessories the car seat manufacturer recommends and to ask their doctor about anything they already bought.

Medically reviewed by Dr. Hooman Melamed, MD, FAAOS CA License A85644 NPI 1447350053 How we review

Transcript

From the video's automatic YouTube captions, edited for punctuation, capitalization and paragraph breaks. Filler sounds such as "um" are left out, and clearly misheard names and medical terms are corrected. Words that could not be made out are marked [inaudible].

Read the full transcript

How many of you scrolled through your newsfeed to find a shocking headline or a trend that promises outrageous health benefits? We give you our opinion in What’s the Real Deal. Recently, we’re gonna be talking about a mother who shared her mom hack on Instagram: a fabric band across her little one’s forehead to keep his head from drooping when he dozed off in his car seat. But not too much later, she reposted it with a stern warning: do not do this, I was wrong, this could lead to internal decapitation. That post went viral.

What is the real deal? We asked our good friend, orthopedic spine surgeon Dr. Hooman Melamed, to join us and help talk about this, because from the outside looking in at this whole scenario, you can understand how a parent would think, oh, the baby looks more comfortable if they fall asleep, you know, putting one of these around their head would be a good idea. But what’s, what’s going on with these?

Absolute, absolute no. I cannot emphasize how dangerous these are. I know everybody has a good intention. You don’t want the head to fall, you want to keep the neck straight, which is fine, but this is the worst thing you can do. Why? Because God forbid in an accidents, you, there’s a, what she said is absolutely correct, internal decapitation, meaning that the head, which is a skull, the occiput, and the neck, the cervix, they dissociate from each other, and they basically, it snaps internally. Can lead to immediate death, right? It’s, it’s basically, I mean, the death rate is over 99 percent. Look, if you want to stabilize the neck, you use a neck brace. That’s right. In medicine, it’s not as though someone has an unstable neck or cervical spine, you deal with it up here.

And what’s kind of scary is this particular one we got online for $8 and had over 450 reviews, 73% giving four-plus stars, because those are the parents who hadn’t had the problematic experience. That’s right. There were some with one stars that said things like, this nearly killed our baby, and not safe, be careful. How does a parent, you know, when they’re evaluating situations like this, how does a parent know to be careful?

One of them is that people don’t realize this thing can actually come down and choke around your neck as well too. You can actually come down, it can, you know, all these spots where it could cause problems. Exactly. Or they can block their mouth, you know, so all kinds of… But most importantly, you have to look at the manufacturing company you’re buying it from. Do they recommend this product? Does it go with it? You know, you really have to look. I know you’re trying to do the right thing, but sometimes doing the right thing, you can actually do more harm.

So in other words, if you have this brand of car seat, only buy products that are made for this. That’s exactly right. From the manufacturer, that have passed all the safety protocols. That’s right. And whatnot. Don’t self-accessorize. Exactly.

And this is one of the great fears I have with online sales. You know, realistically, you would like to believe that some of the, the brick-and-mortar stores that you go into, if they sell a particular car seat, they’re not going to sell accessories that are potentially dangerous, or at least they should not. But you can go online and unwittingly buy things that are harmful to you or your child. If you’re not sure and you already have bought something, take it, take it to your doctor and say, hey, I bought this, maybe I spent a hundred bucks on it, and is it worth me using this, or is it just throw it away?

Browse all videos in the Video Hub

Patients on Google

Recent Google reviews

4.9 633 Google reviews
  • Renee Smith
    Rated 5 out of 5.

    Dr. Melemed is truly the best! He genuinely cares about his patients, and it shows in every aspect of the care he provides. I recently had an outpatient procedure, and I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with the surgery center. …

  • Phyllis Sorbet
    Rated 5 out of 5.

    Dr Hooman Melamed and the entire clinic are extremely personable and professional. They listen and understand all your concerns and issues and come up with the best plan for your situation. I have had a very positive experience and successful surgery. …

  • Melina Rodriguez
    Rated 5 out of 5.

    Dr. Melamed is an exceptional physician. I initially came to him for my spine concerns, but he took the time to look at the bigger picture, truly listen, and help me find the right resources and specialists for a separate, complex medical condition outside his specialty. …

  • mk4uandme
    Rated 5 out of 5.

    I had a disc replacement almost a year ago. I feel much better. I chose him to be my surgeon because he came highly recommended from several different sources. Last month, Dr. Melemed Noticed something wrong in the current x-ray compared to a few months ago. …

  • Mark Myers
    Rated 5 out of 5.

    I was incapacitated, couldn’t stand, sit or walk. The pain was excruciating. I’ll spare you the diagnosis, but it was serious. I could only lie down with my foot up to reduce the pain. It required EMERGENCY surgery. …

Reviews from Google Individual results vary.

Second opinions welcome

Not sure if surgery is the answer? Neither are we — until we've seen your MRI.

Send your imaging for a personal review with Dr. Melamed. Many patients learn a smaller, muscle-sparing option is on the table.