Video · The Doctors segment
Published on YouTube Length 4:54
The hosts talk with Frank, a Long Island, New York man who got a bill for over 650 thousand dollars after emergency back surgery that his insurance company said was not medically necessary. Dr. Melamed says the MRI he saw showed severe narrowing of the entire spinal canal and that the surgery was the right call. He says insurance denials are becoming more and more common, and that he often ends up talking to reviewers who are not spine surgeons.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hooman Melamed, MD, FAAOS CA License A85644 NPI 1447350053 How we review
From the video's automatic YouTube captions, edited for punctuation, capitalization and paragraph breaks. Filler sounds such as "um" are left out, and clearly misheard names and medical terms are corrected. Words that could not be made out are marked [inaudible].
Surprise medical bills have become so common in the U.S., they affect more than half of the population. Today, in our ongoing series Money vs. Medicine, we’re covering one man whose emergency surgery left him with a massive financial fallout. A Long Island, New York man was experiencing back pain so bad he couldn’t walk, when a doctor told him he needed to have surgery immediately or risk being paralyzed. He chose that, the surgery. The good news, the surgery was a success. Then not so favorable news when the bill came. The man was left in shock. That total bill came out to over 650 thousand dollars. This leaves the very large question: are the soaring medical costs worth the care, or are patients being taken advantage of?
We have Frank join us today via Skype. Frank, let me just cut to the chase. How did this end up being a bill for over 650 thousand dollars?
Not that part of it, I, I couldn’t tell you. I [inaudible] what’s gonna happen.
And when you went in to get this surgery, you were pretty much wheelchair bound, is that accurate? You were in that much pain, and the doctor said they were worried about you becoming paralyzed. So you pretty much just said, okay, healthcare system, I’m in dire straits here. I’m assuming, because in your mind this was an emergency surgery, you weren’t sitting around thinking about, well, how much is this gonna cost me. Did anyone even discuss cost with you before you were wheeled into surgery?
No, there’s never any discussion. It’s was mostly about severity of my situation. The bone spur and herniation was severe, pushed the nerve out so bad they had to put a special machine on it just to see if it was coming back.
But your insurance company basically said they weren’t going to cover it regardless, correct?
They started out saying that they felt the surgery was not necessary, medically necessary.
So we’re going to break this down, Frank. We’re joining our audience by orthopedic spine surgeon Dr. Hooman Melamed. And Dr. Mel, but I want to talk about the medicine side first, okay, and then we can talk about the money. So here you have a patient, who I know you’ve reviewed Frank’s case, who is in so much debilitating pain that he has to be wheel-chaired into the hospital, is told by a physician, you need to have this emergency surgery now or you could become paralyzed. So as you’re hearing this, what are your thoughts on that?
I think the decision for medical necessities should be made between the, the doctor and the patient. The insurance company is not allowed to interfere in this process. And you know, if this Frank is in excruciating pain, I saw that MRI, that looks pretty bad. You know, I would probably tell the patient, you need to go. I mean, that is like pretty much compromising, severe narrowing of the entire spinal canal. The whole spinal canal is filled, would like, look at this condition. I mean, that is an emergency surgery, and I think the doctor was right. You got to go to the ER right away, you got to take care of it right away. And for the insurance to say wasn’t medically necessary, it is so like ridiculously outrageous.
Oh, this is very different than the, the cases where we’ve presented and said, okay, this was a not, non-medically necessary procedure, and the, the doctor forcing you into surgery was looking to profit. This was purely, in your mind as an orthopedic surgeon, the right call?
Oh, absolutely, was the right call. And you know, I am have patients myself, and who are not fortunate like Frank, not getting this, this story out there, who are also getting, going there, and the insurance saying you just need a physical therapy, you don’t need to have surgery.
How common is this, Doctor Melamed? What, you’ve had patients you feel surgery is necessary, and then after the fact the insurance company denies it?
It is becoming extremely more and more common, and patients unfortunately are painfully finding that out, that even sometimes the surgery, they say it’s authorized, and they come back and said, oh, it wasn’t necessary.
Dr. Melamed, unfortunately this decision is being made by either a non-doctor or a doctor who’s not specialized in spine surgery.
That’s correct. A lot of times when I talk on the phone, I’m talking to a nurse, a family practice or a general surgeon who have no clue. I mean, it is, they’re just reading some script, and they’re not even listening to the patient’s problem, and they’re, they literally make up, they were making up guidelines. One guy told me, pain is not an indication for surgery. I said, so you’re telling me if the patient is in pain, he cannot have surgeries? Like, no. I said, what do you get these guideline from? They literally makes, making stuff up to avoid paying people for surgery.
Patients on Google
Dr. Melemed is truly the best! He genuinely cares about his patients, and it shows in every aspect of the care he provides. I recently had an outpatient procedure, and I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with the surgery center. …
Dr Hooman Melamed and the entire clinic are extremely personable and professional. They listen and understand all your concerns and issues and come up with the best plan for your situation. I have had a very positive experience and successful surgery. …
Dr. Melamed is an exceptional physician. I initially came to him for my spine concerns, but he took the time to look at the bigger picture, truly listen, and help me find the right resources and specialists for a separate, complex medical condition outside his specialty. …
I had a disc replacement almost a year ago. I feel much better. I chose him to be my surgeon because he came highly recommended from several different sources. Last month, Dr. Melemed Noticed something wrong in the current x-ray compared to a few months ago. …
I was incapacitated, couldn’t stand, sit or walk. The pain was excruciating. I’ll spare you the diagnosis, but it was serious. I could only lie down with my foot up to reduce the pain. It required EMERGENCY surgery. …
Reviews from Google Individual results vary.
Second opinions welcome
Send your imaging for a personal review with Dr. Melamed. Many patients learn a smaller, muscle-sparing option is on the table.