Treatment
Surgical options for a worn-out disc — considered only once it is confirmed as the pain source and conservative care has run its course.
Short answer:
When is surgery considered for degenerative disc disease?
Surgery is considered when a specific worn disc is confirmed as the pain source, the pain meaningfully limits your life, and rest, therapy and injections have not settled it. It is not for diffuse back pain without a clear source. The operation may be a motion-preserving disc replacement or, where the segment is unstable or collapsed, a fusion.
When a disc wears down, it can lose height, inflame the surrounding structures, and become a genuine source of back pain. Degenerative disc surgery addresses that worn disc directly — but only after imaging and your symptoms confirm it is truly the pain generator, and only after conservative care and injections have had a fair trial.
There is no single operation for a degenerated disc. Dr. Melamed matches the procedure to the case, favoring the least-invasive option that will do the job. For the right patient that may mean a motion-preserving disc replacement; for others, where instability or collapse is present, a fusion is the sounder choice. The starting point is always the same: confirm the source, exhaust conservative options, then choose the smallest procedure that solves the problem.
Surgery becomes a reasonable conversation when a specific worn disc is confirmed as the pain source, the pain is meaningfully limiting your life, and rest, therapy, and injections have not settled it. It is not for diffuse back pain without a clear generator, or for people who have not yet exhausted conservative care. Dr. Melamed reviews your imaging, your history, and your goals before recommending whether — and which — surgery fits.
Patients who have not found pain relief through conservative (nonsurgical) care and have suffered a diminution in their quality of life and ability to function because of a symptomatic degenerated disc should educate themselves and discuss the benefits and risks of each type of surgery with their physician.
The worn disc is removed and the space it occupied is addressed in a way suited to your anatomy. Where motion can be safely preserved, an artificial disc maintains movement at that level. Where the segment is unstable or collapsed, a spacer restores height and the level is fused so it heals solid. In both cases, any nerve compression caused by the disc is relieved at the same time.
Dr. Melamed reaches the disc through the least-disruptive route the case allows, using minimally invasive, muscle-sparing technique where suitable so that healthy tissue is spared and recovery is smoother.
Recovery depends on which procedure was the right fit. Motion-preserving options often allow a quicker return to activity, while a fusion heals more gradually over weeks to months as the bone knits. In either case Dr. Melamed emphasizes early guided movement, muscle preservation, and a rehabilitation plan designed to limit reliance on narcotics.
In addition to possibly improving one’s quality of life, there are some benefits to surgery:
There are two main types of surgery used to treat pain and symptoms from lumbar degenerated discs: lumbar fusion surgery and artificial disc replacement.
Lumbar fusion is designed to stabilize or stop the motion of the vertebral segment where the degenerated disc is located. The operation involves accessing the segment through a back and/or stomach incision (both of which require moving muscles and ligaments) and typically inserting hardware (such as pedicle screws) along with an interbody cage, spacers, or structural bone graft to temporarily immobilize the affected segment while the fusion is healing.
Artificial disc replacement, sometimes called total disc replacement (TDR), is a newer and somewhat more complex procedure than fusion.
Artificial disc replacement surgery involves the following steps:
This type of surgery has been available in some countries for a number of years, and in the US, one technology was made generally available in 2004.
Questions, Answered
Dr. Melamed correlates your imaging with your symptoms and exam rather than operating on a scan alone. Surgery is only on the table once a specific disc is confirmed as the pain generator, because degeneration that shows on imaging does not always cause pain.
It depends on the level and its stability. Where motion can be safely kept, an artificial disc is often preferable. Where the segment is unstable or collapsed, a fusion is the sounder choice. Dr. Melamed recommends the least-invasive option that will actually solve your problem.
In almost all cases, yes. Surgery for a degenerative disc is considered only after rest, therapy, and injections have had a fair trial. Options like PRP and cell therapy may be part of that conservative step before any operation is discussed.
Patients on Google
Dr. Melemed is truly the best! He genuinely cares about his patients, and it shows in every aspect of the care he provides. I recently had an outpatient procedure, and I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with the surgery center. …
Dr Hooman Melamed and the entire clinic are extremely personable and professional. They listen and understand all your concerns and issues and come up with the best plan for your situation. I have had a very positive experience and successful surgery. …
Dr. Melamed is an exceptional physician. I initially came to him for my spine concerns, but he took the time to look at the bigger picture, truly listen, and help me find the right resources and specialists for a separate, complex medical condition outside his specialty. …
I had a disc replacement almost a year ago. I feel much better. I chose him to be my surgeon because he came highly recommended from several different sources. Last month, Dr. Melemed Noticed something wrong in the current x-ray compared to a few months ago. …
I was incapacitated, couldn’t stand, sit or walk. The pain was excruciating. I’ll spare you the diagnosis, but it was serious. I could only lie down with my foot up to reduce the pain. It required EMERGENCY surgery. …
Reviews from Google Individual results vary.
Second opinions welcome
Send your imaging for a personal review with Dr. Melamed. Many patients learn a smaller, muscle-sparing option is on the table.