Video · The Doctors segment
Published on YouTube Length 3:33
In this TV segment, Alan Gordon says chronic pain is widely misunderstood and describes a patient whose neck pain went away after she learned to see the sensations as safe. Dr. Hooman Melamed disagrees that doctors aren't trained in pain, pointing to what medical students learn about pain receptors and pharmacology. He does agree there's too much spine surgery, and says the physical exam, history and imaging all have to line up before calling something the source of pain.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hooman Melamed, MD, FAAOS CA License A85644 NPI 1447350053 How we review
From the video's automatic YouTube captions, edited for punctuation, capitalization and paragraph breaks. Filler sounds such as "um" are left out, and clearly misheard names and medical terms are corrected. Words that could not be made out are marked [inaudible].
We are back with Alan Gordon, who claims most pain is in your mind, and orthopedic spine surgeon Dr. Hooman Melamed. Alan, coming back to you. You say that doctors are treating chronic pain all wrong and the issues goes back to the lack of training in medical school. Tell us about that.
You know, Felicia, the woman we just saw, was diagnosed with a 4 mm disc herniation in her neck. She had a lot of pain around that and a lot of fear around it. So, all we did was we helped to teach her brain to reinterpret these sensations as safe and the pain went away. That was 4 years ago. She’s still pain-free. I have a, I have a lot of respect for physicians, but there is a fundamental misunderstanding of chronic pain in the medical community. We need a paradigm shift in the way that chronic pain is treated and understood and we need it now. There’s just too many people suffering.
That’s a very interesting point. Dr. Melamed, to you. You disagree with what Alan says about the lack of training for chronic pain. Is that right?
I think, you know, yes. I mean, I think we learn about pain, you know, from, you guys know, from first 2 years in med school, we learn about pain receptors, the pharmacology. So, we understand that and then during the 2 years in medical school, our last 2 years, we’re on rotation. Every rotation, I mean, we have patients who have pain of something, some kind of pain, something. So, we are familiar with the pain and then we go through our respective residency, whether it’s plastic surgery or psychiatry. I mean, there’s impossible for a patient not to be seeing us because of, because of pain.
But, I do agree with Alan that we do need people understanding more about the psychology of the pain and start utilizing more, especially among surgeons, because I think there’s too much spine surgery that is happening and other musculoskeletal procedures where patients don’t need, and I think we need some better education for that. But at the same time, what I always say is that the physical exam, the history, the imaging, everything has to line up before you can say, “Okay, this is the problem.” Sure, you could have a disc herniation, but I’ve had patients, I’m like, “That’s not your pain. That’s your scoliosis is not causing your pain.”
Sure.
So, yes, more education with understanding pain is better, but I, I don’t agree that doctors don’t know about pain. I think we know a lot about pain. It’s about educating all the providers out there on how, especially spine surgeons, on how to talk to patients.
I think that sums it up pretty darn well, and I want to end it on that note, that, that we hear what Alan is saying, and there is definitely some evidence-based information out there that certain pain with proper guidance, call it psychological
Yep.
intervention, if you will. But in concert with what we learned in medical school about pain and structural issues, I think it’s a meeting of those two schools, meeting of the minds. There’s always room
Balanced approach.
for a balanced approach. There’s always room for improvement, and there’s always room for, for more research and study, but Alan, I think you’re, you’re onto something there, and thanks again for sharing that with us. And Dr. Melamed, as always, a pleasure to have you.
Thank you, guys. Thank you very much for having me. Thank you.
Patients on Google
Dr. Melemed is truly the best! He genuinely cares about his patients, and it shows in every aspect of the care he provides. I recently had an outpatient procedure, and I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with the surgery center. …
Dr Hooman Melamed and the entire clinic are extremely personable and professional. They listen and understand all your concerns and issues and come up with the best plan for your situation. I have had a very positive experience and successful surgery. …
Dr. Melamed is an exceptional physician. I initially came to him for my spine concerns, but he took the time to look at the bigger picture, truly listen, and help me find the right resources and specialists for a separate, complex medical condition outside his specialty. …
I had a disc replacement almost a year ago. I feel much better. I chose him to be my surgeon because he came highly recommended from several different sources. Last month, Dr. Melemed Noticed something wrong in the current x-ray compared to a few months ago. …
I was incapacitated, couldn’t stand, sit or walk. The pain was excruciating. I’ll spare you the diagnosis, but it was serious. I could only lie down with my foot up to reduce the pain. It required EMERGENCY surgery. …
Reviews from Google Individual results vary.
Second opinions welcome
Send your imaging for a personal review with Dr. Melamed. Many patients learn a smaller, muscle-sparing option is on the table.