Video · The Doctors segment
Published on YouTube Length 3:43
On The Doctors, a host calls electric scooters a public safety crisis and describes seeing two kids riding against fast traffic. Dr. Melamed calls the scooters an absolute disaster, saying many riders skip helmets and pads, and lists head trauma, neck injuries and wrist and elbow fractures among the injuries. The panel urges riders to learn how the scooter works before riding in traffic and to wear a helmet.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Hooman Melamed, MD, FAAOS CA License A85644 NPI 1447350053 How we review
From the video's automatic YouTube captions, edited for punctuation, capitalization and paragraph breaks. Filler sounds such as "um" are left out, and clearly misheard names and medical terms are corrected. Words that could not be made out are marked [inaudible].
This is, in my opinion, a public safety crisis. Electric scooters are leading to so many injuries, and in extreme cases we’re even seeing some deaths. One study found 161 percent spike in ER visits involving these electric scooters.
One of the things that I’ve noticed is that kids view these as toys. I was leaving work last week going down Beverly Boulevard, and there were two kids going against traffic. Now, this was a part of the road where there’s absolutely no shoulder, so they were going against traffic that was going 45 miles an hour in the same lane. The cars are going 45 miles outside. We’re not talking about a shoulder, we’re talking about they were, they were going down the same lane with cars rolled 45 miles, and they had these big smiles on their faces, and I kept thinking to myself, 50/50 shot they’re dead within the next 20 minutes.
And, and one of the other things I want to talk about, to get your input, is my issue with these is that, that you can be a novice, not know what you’re doing. They recommend to wear a helmet, but certainly you don’t have to. Your center of gravity is high, which means that when you stop suddenly or you hit a curb, that high center of gravity is by nature going to have a greater effect. Your, your head and neck are following, following a greater distance. As a spine surgeon, what, what are your thoughts?
I think these are absolute disaster. I think too many, I’ve seen, my own niece has it, and I, they don’t wear helmets, you know, which is the worst thing. A lot of people are not wearing helmet, they don’t wear pads like a motorcycle, and there’s no protection, you know. I mean, we see the videos, but there’s far worse. And you’re right, the momentum that carries the person forward, and you’re at the mercy whatever is in front of you, whether it’s the concrete, what is another car or a tree. I mean, and these help head trauma, head trauma, you know, cervical spine injuries, neck injuries, and we’re talking like permanent injuries, everything. Yeah, it’s not worth it, you know. Wrist, wrist fractures, elbow fractures.
Oh, well, these scooters are everywhere, and I do my own social experiment when I go around on my bike downtown, and the number of people I see drinking and getting on the scooter [inaudible] and, you know, that there’s this thought that it’s at night, the car can’t see you, the car making the turn [inaudible] it’s not going to see you. And so I would just urge people, if you choose to use these, there’s nothing wrong with using them, but know what you’re doing, be safe, be aware. If this is your first time on that scooter, make sure you understand how it’s working before you hop off into traffic.
Yeah, go against traffic, and I know it may not be cool, but I can tell you this, wearing a helmet could save your life, and [inaudible] helmet, always, always.
Professional opinion thrown out there, I think that they will be gone at some point. I just, like, they’re everywhere, there’s, they’re right there. It’s a, it’s crazy how they just leave them all over the place. Not only are [inaudible] and they’re leaving, and people were tripping over them.
Yes, and I think they’re fun to ride. I’ve ridden them. I think they’re incredibly [inaudible], they’re fun to ride, are convenient, but the problem is, you know, it’s, it’s a little bit too much right now. So just, just be aware if you’re using these things, know that there have been cases where people have died. So be safe.
Dr. Melamed, permanently injured or [inaudible] permanently disabled, which is the worst thing, to live like that as a young person. Permanent disability, you know, it’s the worst thing.
Dr. Melamed, thank you. [inaudible]
Patients on Google
Dr. Melemed is truly the best! He genuinely cares about his patients, and it shows in every aspect of the care he provides. I recently had an outpatient procedure, and I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with the surgery center. …
Dr Hooman Melamed and the entire clinic are extremely personable and professional. They listen and understand all your concerns and issues and come up with the best plan for your situation. I have had a very positive experience and successful surgery. …
Dr. Melamed is an exceptional physician. I initially came to him for my spine concerns, but he took the time to look at the bigger picture, truly listen, and help me find the right resources and specialists for a separate, complex medical condition outside his specialty. …
I had a disc replacement almost a year ago. I feel much better. I chose him to be my surgeon because he came highly recommended from several different sources. Last month, Dr. Melemed Noticed something wrong in the current x-ray compared to a few months ago. …
I was incapacitated, couldn’t stand, sit or walk. The pain was excruciating. I’ll spare you the diagnosis, but it was serious. I could only lie down with my foot up to reduce the pain. It required EMERGENCY surgery. …
Reviews from Google Individual results vary.
Second opinions welcome
Send your imaging for a personal review with Dr. Melamed. Many patients learn a smaller, muscle-sparing option is on the table.